Atheists: What refutations do you have for the apologetics' evidence for God and Jesus?

I think Jesus existed, but all the "evidence" about his divinity was written by his followers. Not impartial. If Josephus Flavius had reported a man named Jesus Christ going around Israel healing lepers and raising the dead and walking on water [and frankly I think that would be pretty big news, don't you?] then I would be more inclined to agree. It just strikes me as odd how in the period immediately after Jesus' death, if he did the things people said of him, people weren't talking about it.